Learning goal 5n: Explain the limitations of different types
of satellite imagery.
Learning goal 5o: Use satellite imagery to identify low pressure
systems, fronts, and fair weather.
Background
Two characteristics of weather satellites are:
What wavelength bands or channels they can see.
How they orbit the earth.
Different channels from satellites in different orbits have different
advantages. Below, first we discuss channels, then we discuss
orbits.
Channels
Types of Satellite Imagery Channels
Satellites and satellite imagery are very large and extensive topics
within meteorology. Here, we focus on identifying weather features that
could affect your ski day. First, we need to explain the three most
important types of satellite images that meteorologists use to help
them understand the current weather in the atmosphere: visible,
infrared (IR), and water vapour satellites.
Understanding
current conditions is an important step in weather forecasting:
It is very difficult to know what will happen if you
don't know what has happened and what is happening.
By comparing satellite imagery to weather forecast models you can
tell, to an extent, if they are accurately depicting the weather up to
and including the current time.
For example, is the modelled low pressure system or front in the right
location? If the forecast is not currently accurate, then it is
unlikely that it will be accurate farther into the future. If it is
accurate, then you can be more confident in relying on the forecast. If
available, you should always use a satellite movie loop (see below)
instead of a single still frame, since you will see movement and
development of weather features, which will greatly enhance your
interpretation.
Reminder of low pressure system pattern with fronts
To help you interpret satellite imagery, here is a quick
reminder of a low pressure system pattern (Fig. 5no.1). You already
know that low pressure systems have warm and cold fronts. Note that in
the Pacific Northwest, warm fronts are usually a lot shorter than cold
fronts, although the order they appear around the low centre is not
different.
Fig. 5no.1 - Surface weather map for the Northern
Hemisphere with isobars showing a low pressure centre in the middle,
surrounded by regions of relatively higher pressure. The winds travel
counterclockwise around the low pressure. The red line with
semi-circles indicates a warm front, and the blue line with triangles
indicates a cold front. The purple line is an occluded front, where the cold airmass (behind the cold front) has caught up with the warm air mass (associated with the warm front) and under-rides cooler air. The rising motion along all three fronts leads to
condensation of water vapour and usually precipitation. (Credit: West).
Visible Satellite Imagery
Visible satellite imagery shows you a black and white version of
what you would see if you were in space looking down on the earth. The
sunlight illuminates the cloud tops at all levels in the atmosphere.
These show up as light grey and white on the satellite image, and where
there are no clouds, you can see the earth's surface, showing up as
dark grey on the satellite image. The downside of visible imagery is
that you cannot see anything at
nighttime because there is no sunlight.
Interpretation of Visible Satellite Imagery
Fig. 5no.2 - Visible satellite image with
interpreted features, from 3 PM PDT on 13 March 2022. The blue line denotes the
cold front, the red line denotes
the warm front, and the purple line denotes the occluded front.
(a), (b), and (c) are referred to in the text. (Credit: CIRA/RAMMB GOES 17)
Fig. 5no.2 above is a visible satellite image from 3 PM PDT on 13 March 2022. The lines and annotations show a reasonable
interpretation of where the fronts and other features are, as follows:
Symbol "a": approximate low
pressure centre. Click the "Visible Satellite Loop" button below to see
the satellite loop ending at this time. It will will help you see the
rotation around the low. (The loop is dark for the first few frames because it is still nighttime, and visible imagery is not available at night.)
Blue line: cold front associated with
the low pressure system. Remember that a cold front is always drawn on
the warm side of the frontal zone, so most of the frontal clouds appear
just behind the front, as the cold airmass wedges under and
lifts the warmer air ahead of it. Cold fronts usually extend quite far
south from low pressure systems. You can watch it develop in the loop.
Red line: warm front associated with
the low pressure system. Remember that the warm front is also always
drawn on the warm side of the frontal zone, so a lot of the clouds
appear ahead of it, as the warm air rises up slowly
over the cooler air ahead of it. In the Pacific Northwest, warm fronts
are usually quite a bit shorter than cold fronts and can be harder to
identify.
Purple line: occluded front, which extends from
the junction of the warm and cold fronts back towards the low centre.
You can watch the occlusion elongate in the loop (it is easier to see
in conjunction with the IR loop discussed next). Occlusions typically
occur where the cold airmass has caught up with the warm air and is under-riding it, so clouds also appear just ahead of the front.
Symbol "b": clear air. You can
interpret the dark greys as ocean and land, since you would see light
greys or white if there were clouds present.
Symbol "c": also clear air. You have to be careful
here, because the white pattern under the "c" isn't clouds. This is fresh snow on the ground over northern B.C.!.
This would
be slightly more obvious on a more zoomed-in satellite image, where you
can make out the terrain better. The lesson here is to consider if there are snow-capped mountains or if the temperatures have been cold enough for snowfall. A good clue is that snow on the ground or in the mountains doesn't move, whereas clouds do, so again the loop is useful here.
Practice.
Here is a visible satellite photo of two occluding cyclones near each
other in the N. Pacific Ocean in Feb 2020. You can see Vancouver
Island outlined in white near the center of the right edge of the
photo. See if you can identify the main components of each
cyclone.
From CIRA / RAMMBS display of US NOAA satellite images. http://rammb.cira.colostate.edu/
Infrared Satellite Imagery
You have already viewed IR satellite images in Snow
Modules A and B. IR sensors detect radiation in the thermal part of the
spectrum, i.e. how hot or cold objects are. The amount of IR radiation
reaching the satellite depends on
the temperature of the object emitting that radiation.
Interpretation of IR Satellite Imagery
Fig. 5no.3 Infrared satellite image with
interpreted features, from 3 PM PDT on 13 March 2022. The blue line denotes the
cold front, the red line denotes
the warm front, and the purple line denotes the occluded front.
(a), (b), and (c) are explained in the text. (Credit: CIRA/RAMMB GOES 17)
The infrared (IR) image detects the temperature of objects (clouds, ocean, ground) that are emitting radiation. The warmer temperatures come from objects lower in the atmosphere,
like low clouds, the ground, and the ocean - these show up as dark
greys. Low clouds can be difficult or impossible to distinguish from
the ground because they have a similar temperature. Medium-altitude clouds are cooler, and appear in the image as medium to lighter greys. Cold temperatures
come from objects higher in the atmosphere, like higher cloud tops -
these show up as /blue/green etc. The highest cloud tops
here (green over the northeast Pacific Ocean) are around -60°C!
Note that you can only infer where cloud-tops
are from IR images. That means you can't distinguish between high, thin
clouds (cirrus) that contain little moisture and are not a weather
hazard, and deep storm clouds that span much of depth of the
troposphere and bring bad weather, based on temperatures alone.
However, you can often infer storm and frontal locations by
their shape and organization. Also, on a sunny afternoon,
the land heats up sufficiently to appear almost black (the left, warmer
end of the scale), but the ocean does not change temperature as much as
the land, and therefore does not change colour as much. The best course
of action is to use visible and IR satellite images together to
deduce where threatening clouds or clear air are located.
Fig. 5no.3 above is an IR satellite image from the same
time, roughly 3 PM PDT on 13 March 2022. The lines and annotations are in the same
place:
Symbol "a": approximate low pressure centre. The IR
satellite loop below will help you see the rotation around the low to
deduce where the centre lies.
Blue line: cold front
associated with the low pressure system. The high cloud tops
(dark blues / greens) are mostly behind the front. Since we recognize
the clouds along the blue line as a cold front, we can infer that it
likely has deep (lower-, middle-, and upper-tropospheric) moisture with
it.
Red line: warm front. The high cloud tops appear ahead
of it, with the highest clouds a short way ahead, as the warm airmass
rises up slowly over the cooler air ahead of it. Often some of the high
clouds well ahead of the warm front are just high cirrus clouds. Closer
to the front deeper moisture is found.
Purple line: occluded front. This was mostly
interpreted by looking at the visible
satellite, since there are no high cloud tops.
From the visible satellite, we know that symbol "b"
shows the location of clear air. However, on an IR satellite image, the
ocean shows up lighter than the land (to the northeast of "b") because
the land heats up more during the day. At 3 pm in March, the land would
be warmer than the ocean. You also know that "b" is not an area
with high cloud tops so it helps support your decision from looking at
the visible image.
From the visible satellite, we also know that symbol
"c" shows the location of clear air. This is harder to see on IR
than the visible satellite, and I would hesitate in interpreting it as
clear air until I had looked at a visible satellite for the same time.
Nighttime blindspot
The main limitation of visible imagery (not visible at night), and the
main limitation of IR imagery (difficult to see low clouds), combine
forces during ski season. Often valley cloud forms at night
(particularly in the BC Interior) under a high pressure pattern. Since
valley cloud is nearly impossible to see on either visible or IR
imagery in the early morning in winter, it can leave forecasters with a
bit of a blind spot. The best tool to overcome this is looking at
surface observations. Some weather stations, particularly those located
at airports, will report cloud cover and visibility overnight. Looking
at mountain webcams at sunrise can help as well.
Water Vapour Satellite Imagery
Water vapour satellite imagery is not actually useful for
looking at the water vapour that plays a major role in our sensible
weather, i.e. the water vapour near and at the surface of the earth.
Instead, it shows water vapour in the upper half of the troposphere. It
is mentioned here because it can be useful in the absence of visible
and/or IR satellite imagery, but it is really only useful for looking
at large-scale flow and features in the upper levels of the atmosphere.
These aspects of the atmosphere are not covered in this course, so
interpretation of water vapour imagery is likewise not covered.
Here is a table summarizing how to identify different weather
features on visible and IR satellite imagery. Limitations are also
listed.
Table. 5no.1 - Summary of how to identify weather
features (row headers) with useful types of satellite imagery (column
headers). Also shown is limitations of the types of satellite imagery.
(Credit: Howard and West).
Geocolor Satellite Imagery
The new geostationary satellites have many channels (e.g., visible colours, IR and others) that can be combined to give a very useful geocolor satellite image that looks realistic both day and night. Figure 4 shows a sample, for roughly the same time and date as the images above.
Fig. 5no.4. Geocolor satellite image, from 3:20 PM PDT on 13 March 2022. (Credit: CIRA/RAMMB GOES 17)
Orbits
Geostationary Satellites (GOES):
Geostationary satellites are "parked" over the equator at a fixed longitude. An advantage is that they are good for taking time-lapse photos that you can view as a movie loop. The disadvantage
is that they are so far away from Canada that they get a very oblique
(slant) view of the provinces, and cannot see the northern parts of the
territories and Arctic Canada at all.
To see a movie for the whole hemisphere, using visible light in daytime
and IR at night, my favorite is the following. Also, you can
double click on a location to zoom in to extremely high resolution (but
these zoomed movies takes a long time to download to your computer):
Polar-orbiting satellites go (almost) over the North
and South poles. While they orbit the earth, the earth turns
underneath them. As a result, during each one orbit of the
satellite, it observes a north-south swath of the earth's surface at
high resolution. By the end of the day, enough swaths have been
collected that they can be stitched together in the computer to make a
single image of the whole globe. The advantage is that they have an excellent, vertical (straight down) view of Canada including the Canadian Arctic. The disadvantages
are that you get only one global image per day, and each swath is
photographed about 100 minutes earlier or later than the neighboring
swath. Here is my favorite site, which is also zoomable: